Escaping Excel Anarchy: The Hidden Problems of Excel

Excel remains a cornerstone tool in financial services due to its accessibility, flexibility, and powerful data manipulation capabilities. Its intuitive interface and widespread adoption empower business users to perform complex calculations, build financial models, and easily generate reports. This accessibility fosters innovation, enabling teams to respond quickly to evolving business needs without waiting for IT intervention; in other words, it helps employees bridge the gap between system limitations and critical business requirements.

Excel’s ability to support rapid prototyping and iterative problem-solving makes it an indispensable asset in a dynamic industry landscape. Despite its strengths, unchecked reliance on Excel, especially in core processes, can lead to “Excel anarchy,” where the rampant spread of siloed spreadsheets fragments operations, increases operational risk, stifles scalability, and blocks cross-functional collaboration.

The Hidden Risks of Excel Dependency

More definitively, over-reliance on Excel in financial firms introduces a wide range of operational risks that can compromise data integrity, compliance, development, and business continuity. Some of the more straightforward risks include:

  1. Human Error & Data Integrity Issues

Manual inputs, broken formulas, and inconsistent file handling expose firms to significant errors. Even minor changes to spreadsheet logic can cascade into flawed results, particularly when used for reporting, risk, or performance analysis.

  1. Lack of Version Control & Reproducibility

Losing control of what work was done historically makes it difficult to track changes or reproduce results. Spreadsheets often lack audit trails, making it difficult to trace or reproduce outputs, especially when used in regulatory reporting or client-facing materials. In environments where templates evolve informally over time, inconsistencies can become embedded in core processes.

  1. Security & Shadow IT Exposure

Another common but concerning risk is the use of Excel macros in core processes to run queries directly against enterprise databases. While convenient, this can expose hard-coded credentials, bypass access controls, and allow unauthorized data access. When shared across teams, these macros become difficult to govern or audit, creating a shadow IT layer that undermines enterprise security.

  1. Over-Reliance

Excel fosters siloed, bespoke solutions that lack integration with broader systems, fragmenting operations and reducing transparency. This fragmentation grows over time and leads teams to gradually act independently to build their own in-house solutions.  Across an organization, this hinders collaboration, scalability, and auditability, ultimately stalling innovation and increasing systemic operational risk. Ironically, this leaves firms dependent on Excel to try to fix the problems that Excel created in the first place, only digging the hole deeper.

Striking the Right Balance, Taking Back Control

Losing control of what work was done historically makes it difficult to track changes or reproduce results. To mitigate the inherent risks of overreliance on Excel without stifling innovation, firms must strike a deliberate balance between user empowerment and governance. This equilibrium varies based on organizational structure, culture, and risk tolerance. Achieving this balance requires a structured, phased approach beginning with the identification and documentation of critical Excel-based processes. This might involve steps such as:

  1. Inventory & Assess Critical Spreadsheets

Begin with a comprehensive inventory of spreadsheets involved in essential processes. Prioritize those impacting reporting, compliance, or performance measurement.

  1. Categorize by Risk & Strategic Fit

Classify spreadsheets based on complexity, business impact, and risk. Outcomes may include:

  • Migration to enterprise-grade platforms
  • Replacement with configurable tools
  • Governance overlay to ensure auditability

  1. Deploy the Right Technologies

Today’s market offers a range of modern data management vendors that can help firms strike the right balance between flexibility and governance:

  • Snowflake provides a scalable data infrastructure
  • Arcesium Aquata offers integrated investment data management
  • Coherent Spark converts spreadsheets into governed, API-ready applications
  • Other platforms enable centralized oversight without restricting end-user flexibility

  1. Build and Execute a Strategic Roadmap

Sequence governance initiatives according to business risk and value. Develop a timeline for deprecation, migration, or reinforcement, supported by cross-functional alignment and change management.

Excel Isn’t the Enemy, Lack of Governance Is

Excel remains a valuable tool for business users, but when it evolves into the default system of records, it becomes a liability. Excel Anarchy hinders collaboration, increases risk, and restricts growth.

Restoring order doesn’t mean eliminating Excel. It means elevating it, placing it within a governed, auditable framework that supports both operational excellence and business agility. For firms focused on modernization and scalability, reclaiming control over Excel is not just a best practice; it’s a strategic imperative.

Why Meradia

Meradia delivers value not just as a trusted advisor, but as a transformation partner. We help investment managers and asset owners move beyond spreadsheet sprawl by diagnosing Excel dependencies, designing right-sized governance models, and implementing scalable, enterprise-ready solutions.

With deep expertise in performance measurement, operational transformation, and investment data architecture, Meradia enables clients to:

  • Uncover hidden risks and inefficiencies
  • Establish governance without compromising agility
  • Future-proof critical workflows
  • Regain control while preserving the flexibility Excel offers

Whether you’re looking to streamline reporting, reduce operational risk, or scale with confidence, Meradia brings the strategy, structure, and experience to make it happen.

Download Thought Leadership ArticleServices: , , Expertises: Clients: Authors:

Jim Turner

Jim Turner is a seasoned financial services professional dedicated to improving clients’ operations through data-driven strategies. With over 20 years of front, middle, and back-office experience, Jim has worked extensively throughout operations and technology landscapes in the industry and has worked with a wide variety of financial systems from the front and back end. Jim has experienced these landscapes as a front-end operational user, SQL SME, business analyst, data analyst, implementation specialist, solutions specialist, and product manager. With a diverse background across many functions, Jim supports Meradia’s global portfolio of clients as a member of the Data practice through his understanding and ability to mine and leverage the spectrum of underlying data that drives all aspects of the industry.

Skip to content